Frequently Asked Questions

About Us

What is NYC Crit Club?

NYC Crit Club is a radical alternative program offering community, connection, and critique to artists post BFA and MFA, as well as self-taught artists. The fundamental mission of the organization is to offer the highest level of critique, dialogue and community support without financial stress and to be as inclusive as possible in all ways. Through our programming we seek to support and strengthen artists’ work while building relationships between artists, gallerists, writers and curators. 

We provide a range of programs + opportunities:
- 6-8 week online + in-person courses (Winter, Spring, Summer + Fall)
-
The Canopy Program, a year-long mentorship intensive
-
Independent Study Program
-
Portfolio Reviews
-
The Plum Lime Residency
-
Artist Lecture Series Club

How did NYC Crit Club start?

The first small iteration of NYC Crit Club began in the Summer of 2017 by Hilary Doyle. A few months later in the Fall of 2017 Catherine Haggarty joined and together the program has grown and evolved organically to meet the demand of artists' needs while maintaining its inclusivity and seriousness. Catherine Haggarty and Hilary Doyle have built NYC Crit Club into a far-reaching project with over 500 artists in our alumni network, hundreds of critics and faculty and specifically designed courses that speak to contemporary issues in art.

What is special about the NYC Crit Club?

NYC Crit Club is run by artists for artists. The range of faculty expertise and experience is strong in both the worlds of academia and exhibitions. NYC Crit Club + Canopy Program faculty teach part time at RISD, Brown University, Purchase College, Rutgers, SVA, and beyond. Our faculty are esteemed artists, curators, and gallery directors that are eager to work in a non-institutional setting with motivated artists. Take a look at our faculty roster! We also pride ourselves on the incredible group of artists, critics, writers, and gallerists we invite each year as Visiting Critics + Guest Speakers, learn more here!

Why should I participate with NYC Crit Club?

NYC Crit Club is what artists make for themselves and offers a range of opportunities and networks that will strengthen your studio practice, lead to new inspiration and connect you with a community of peers, both local + around the world!

We strive to be low cost and are committed to designing programs that allows for flexibility in time commitment, as artists can elect to be involved as much as they can manage and are always welcome to return. Time is a valuable commodity that is not afforded to all - so our programming is angled to support those who are ready, serious and excited to improve while they maintain balance with their studio, work and life commitments. Our programs are designed for the working and serious artist.

Participating with NYC Crit Club is an amazing gateway to community!

Additionally, many artists have grown and used NYC Crit Club as a springboard for success, such as group shows, residencies, or getting accepted into MFA programs. Others have built a portfolio of work towards a group or solo show and have decided perhaps they don’t need or want to attend an MFA. 

Since NYC Crit Club is an organization built by artists for artists - there are often exhibition opportunities through our programming. Many members of NYC Crit Club go on to curate exhibitions themselves as well!

Is NYC Crit Club a replacement for an MFA?

We are not an accredited institute and don’t strive to be. We are interested in offering a space for artists post school - be it BFA or MFA. We can’t provide what MFA programs provide in terms of two years of intensive coursework and a studio. However, we provide the same high level of dialogue, faculty credibility and community that one may receive with a MFA program - but without the debt.

What is NYC Crit Club's Diversity and Inclusion Philosophy?

NYC Crit Club values equity and justice for artists of all backgrounds. It is our intent that artists from diverse backgrounds and perspectives be well-served and represented by NYC Crit Club. The diversity that artists bring to courses is viewed with respect as a strength, benefit and asset in our courses. It is our goal to present materials and activities that are inclusive and respectful of diversity: gender, sexual orientation, disability, age, socioeconomic status, ethnicity, race, culture, education, and other background characteristics. NYC Crit Club offers financial aid and BIPOC scholarships as part of our commitment to serving artists inclusively.

Read more about Diversity and Inclusion within NYC Crit Club.

Your suggestions about how to improve the value of diversity in this course are encouraged and appreciated. Please let us know ways to improve the effectiveness of our commitment to respect and equality for you personally or for others anytime by emailing us at nyc.critclub@gmail.com.

We also offer scholarships for BIPOC artists in need. 


The Canopy Program

What is The Canopy Program?

The Canopy Program is a year-long intimate program, providing artists access to work exclusively with a Faculty Mentor and a Cohort of 10 artists for three semesters. Cohorts are available virtually via Zoom for artists based across the world, in-person Cohorts are available for artists living in the New York City area.

Artists will meet regularly throughout the program’s year for critiques, discussion and resource building in professional practices and art history lectures. Each Cohort will receive the opportunity to engage in special workshops, lectures and critique with Guest Speakers, Visiting Artists + Critics. Each Cohort will culminate in a pop-up group show with an opening reception in New York City at the end of program!

View The Canopy Program’s FAQs to learn more!


NYC Crit Club Courses

Where are courses held?

We provide online + in-person courses.

Online courses are held virtually via Zoom and are open to artists around the world.
In-person courses are hosted at our studio in Chelsea (NYC).

What types of courses are offered?

Course offerings change each semester + new courses are continuously being developed! Courses are available 4 times a year; Winter, Spring, Summer + Fall.

Online Courses:

  • Visiting Critic Programs

  • Group Critiques

  • The Crit Assignment

  • Art History + Writing Seminars

  • Materials + Techniques

In Person Courses:

  • Drawing Salon

  • Group Critiques

  • Demystifying the Art World

  • Materials + Techniques

How does showing work online work? Is this just as good as sharing work in person?

Artists share work online via Zoom by screen sharing images of their work with the group and faculty. Advantages of this include that artists can share more work easily, including images of large work, installation, writing, video, and etc.

Note: Performance must be shared via video documentation.

Can I drop in on a course?

Drop ins are not permitted. We offer 5-6 week courses, making it easier for busy artists to enroll. If you are short on time or cannot commit to a 6 - 8 week course, we recommend checking out our Independent Study Program if you are seeking feedback on your work!

What is the Visiting Critics Program?

Overview

The Visiting Critic program offers in-depth feedback, exposure and connections with 4 respected art world critics, well known artists, and/or influential curators. Each visiting guest critic will introduce themselves with a brief talk and Q+A. Next, artists in the course present online slideshows of their artworks and prepare questions for faculty, critics and peers. This program helps take one’s work, thinking and process in new and exciting directions.

Artists in the Visiting Critic Program:

  • Will participate in a class of 10 artists max.

  • Make connections with 4 Visiting Critics

  • Learn from and enjoy talks & critiques by Visiting Critics 

  • Have work paired with Visiting Critics who are the best fit for their work and practice

  • Meet for 6 weekly, 3 hour classes online via Zoom

  • Receive 2+ opportunities for critiques & feedback. Each artist will receive feedback via their introduction on the first day and through out the course each artist will receive two long 15 - 20 minute crits w/ select Visiting Critics

  • Collaborate with artist peers in Zoom studio visits outside of class 

  • Receive feedback + challenges to reinvigorate each artist’s approach and artistic practice

What is the Art Career Intensive course?

Art Career Intensive is the perfect course for artists who want to realize their professional aspirations. Each Art Career Intensive is designed specifically with key focuses on topics such as communication, applications + writing, and website/social media presentations, etc. Artists enrolled in this course will be able to share their work + writing for constructive feedback and guidance.

Select Guest Speakers are invited to present talks and provide advice based on their professional experiences. Art Career Intensives are typically online courses hosted via Zoom.

What type of courses are offered in the Seminar + Art History department?

The Seminar and Art History Department was born out of the need to expand on conversations within the critique courses. Over the years, we have noticed that continuing the conversation about major topics in Modernism or art theory were needed. For years we have been expanding the ideas about how to write about art, how to better discuss terms and language within art and how to contextualize history to one’s own work.

The seminars range from theory of Drawing & Painting to intensives on writing and poetry and Queer Art History. All Seminars are led in a way where the artists are working with faculty on selected readings and films to contextualize content. Presentations are given weekly and discussion groups in out-of-class meet ups build relationships and give voice to artists within an open discussion in class. 

No seminars or art history courses are pure lectures - as we value and understand the voice of the NYC Crit Club artists. The faculty guides and shapes conversations in an inclusive way to highlight varying degrees of experience and questions within a group setting. The Seminars and Art History courses are ideal for an artist who needs a break discussing their work but seek to further the ideas of their thinking and research within the art historical canon.

 

Eligibility for Courses

Who is eligible for courses?

Courses are designed for serious visual artists. Participants currently range in age from 22 to 70 years old. Most participants have received a BFA or MFA prior to attending a course. Self-taught artists are welcomed.

For critique based courses, we recommend that all artists have a body of work that exemplifies their dedication to their artistic practice. All participants must be open to the critique process, as that is the foundation of the process.

If you are a curator, writer, and/or gallerist, you are welcome to enroll in an Art History + Writing Seminar course.

Do you need an art degree to participate?

A BFA or MFA degree are not required to enroll or apply. We value experience in the world outside the art academy and understand not everyone might have gotten the chance to study art but can bring unique knowledge in other fields. This is one of the strengths of NYC Crit Club, highlighting diversity in knowledge, experience, age and research.

Is Financial Aid available for courses?

For those in need of payment assistance, we offer financial aid & payment plans.

In addition, we offer BIPOC Scholarships reserved for Black, Indigenous, and People of Color artists, to receive a discount of 25-50% off the course cost.


The Artist Lecture Series Club - Membership

What is the Artist Lecture Series Club - Membership?

The NYC Crit Club online membership program, the Artist Lecture Series Club, was created to help further members’ art practice and career goals through artist lectures and career resources.

This year long membership provides artists, who might not be able to take a course, access to a series of Zoom artist lectures + Q&A with internationally acclaimed artists, NYC Crit Club discounts and resources.

Artist Lecture Series Club Membership benefits include:

  • Exclusive access to Artist Lectures via Zoom

  • 5% discount code for any course

  • $10 off code for Plum Lime Residency application

  • Access to Members Resource area

    • recommendations for open call opportunities

    • virtual library

    • lecture archive


Independent Study Program

What is the Independent Study Program?

The Independent Study Program (ISP) provides artists with a Zoom studio visit with NYC Crit Club Faculty.

The one-on-one virtual visit will include a consultation about your current artistic goals and aspirations, such as improving and developing your work, professional practices, and life plan as an artist.

Each ISP meeting is 1 hr. for $200.

May I sign up for a single Independent Study Program (ISP) session or is it an ongoing commitment?

Yes, you are welcome to book one session at a time, or multiple sessions.

If you are booking your first ISP session, we recommend booking one meeting to start before committing to other sessions.

How is payment accepted for the Independent Study Program (ISP)?

Payment is required when booking your ISP appointment.

Please email Amanda if you have any questions at amanda.critclub@gmail.com.


Misc. Inquiries

I am a member who wants to share a solo show, classified or open call? What do I do?

Send an image + info via Direct Message on Instagram to @nyccritclubopenings! Artist, Ray Hwang, manages this page and will promote your exhibition or open call opportunity via @nyccritclubopenings!

I am an artist, curator, writer or gallery director, can I join NYC Crit Club as a Visiting Critic or Guest Speaker

If you are interested in joining us as a Critic or Guest Speaker, please complete the Work With Us intake form and we will reach out to you for more information.